What if citizens had a say in the city budget? There are surely some people who would immediately start protesting against this idea. They probably think that the budgets of our towns or countries can only be designed by knowledgeable economic experts and politicians. But why wouldn’t we let citizens themselves make decisions about certain budgetary questions? Why couldn’t they bring their own unique perspectives, experience and needs to the table, deliberate in the spirit of cooperation and come to informed decisions together? Participatory budgeting gives the opportunity to citizens to do just that – and the process has now started in Budapest too.
What is participatory budgeting about?
Participatory budgeting is an umbrella term that covers different mechanisms and methods through which citizens can directly influence the use of public funds and determine the investment and expenditure priorities important to them as a community. Participatory budgeting is in fact a way to allow citizens to decide how a local, regional or national decision making body should spend part of the public budget.
In the past three decades citizens in many parts of the world have been involved in the planning of local budgets. The birthplace of the method is Porto Alegre in Brazil, where participatory budgeting was first introduced in 1988, and has since been implemented by more than 2700 governments worldwide. Results have been encouraging, demonstrating many positive impacts of participatory budgeting: it increases transparency, accountability, improves democratic skills and tax morale, and citizens gain a better understanding of the trade-offs to consider during budgetary planning.
Involving the residents of Budapest in the planning of the city budget
In 2020, for the first time in Hungary, the leaders of Budapest decided to give residents the opportunity to decide about the use of 1 billion forints of the city budget. The participatory budgeting process started with an open call for ideas on the 1st October 2020. By the end of the year, nearly 700 ideas were submitted on the public idea website. The Council of Budapest then conducted a formal check of the proposals and clustered the ideas (duplicate ideas or ideas that were nearly the same were grouped together), leaving a total of 142 ideas in the competition.
Citizens’ jury of the participatory budgeting process
The assessment and further narrowing of the 142 ideas was the responsibility of a citizens’ jury of a randomly selected representative group of adult Budapest residents. The design of the methodology and process of the jury’s work, as well as the implementation of the two day event was done by DemNet as an independent, external partner to the Council. The jury worked throughout one weekend, and all sessions were held online due to the COVID-19 situation. Participants were assisted by ten facilitators, and the jury’s mandate was to decide which of the 142 ideas will go to a final vote, where all Budapest residents can participate.
It was very inspiring for us to meet and work together with the participants, and we are proud to have gotten the chance to contribute to the first ever completely online citizen deliberation in Hungary. We were also very pleased to have received plenty of positive feedback from the participants. We were happy to hear them describe the process as progressive and forward-thinking, with a great awareness raising impact, and with an approach that fosters new and real exchange of opinions instead of focusing on debate.
The people of Budapest are now voting
As a result of the citizens’ jury of the participatory budgeting process, 53 ideas were placed on the final ballot representing a total estimated cost of 3,9 billion forints. Given that the size of the participatory budget is only 1 billion forints, a great deal depends on how many votes each idea will get. Residents of Budapest have until the end of June to decide which ideas to fund from the participatory budget.