Written by: Ágnes Győr
We know that women and men use cities in very different ways all over the world but when Eva Kail was a university student, this approach to urban planning was still very new and viewed with great skepticism. Today she is one of the leading experts internationally in gender planning and gender mainstreaming. Over the past decades she and her colleagues have done a great deal to ensure that women are visible in Vienna, that their needs, knowledge and experience are reflected by the way the city looks and works. Recently we had the honor to visit her at her office in Vienna. During our stay she talked to us about how her career began, what the key to Vienna’s success is, the challenges urban planning is facing today and why she believes citizen participation will become much more important in the future.
When it comes to gender inclusive urban planning you are an international household name but when you started your career this term didn’t exist. How did you find this specific field?
E.K.: The second wave of the women’s movement was taking place when I was a student at the Vienna University of Technology (Technischen Universität Wien) so naturally I read a lot of feminist literature. In the beginning though I didn’t connect these to my planning studies. But there was already a kind of feminist German planning literature and in the 70s, there were already feminist architects. For example the short story Unter den Linden by Christa Wolf was published in 1974 in which the female protagonist describes how she uses the public cityscape of Berlin’s Unter den Linden. The novel is a sociological analysis of urban space and expresses worries about the ramifications of mass culture for urban life.
Around that time in Berlin there was also a heated debate about IBA (International Building Exhibition Berlin). IBA was an urban renewal project in West Berlin (1979-1987) and many felt that it excluded women. As a form of protest the Feminist Organisation of Architects and Planners (FOPA) was created in 1981 with the specific aim to reduce discrimination against women in the profession and the built environment in general. So there were all these things going on and they were very inspirational. An important German architecture and design magazine (Arch+) made an issue that was completely dedicated to gender planning, though at the time they called it “women’s issues in planning”. I read it and it was really an eye opener for me.
Did it seem like a radical idea to most people at the time that women and men use cities in different ways?
E.K.: I think it was a little bit up in the air because it was a new approach. And for some, mainly young female planners it was quite a hot topic but the mainstream part of our field was very skeptical. Forty years ago we were not so multicultural, not so well connected. I was really inspired and interested in what was going on in Germany and Switzerland. At the time only the German speaking countries had more intense exchange.
What was the first project that tested the theory in Vienna?
E.K.: I read about an exhibition that female planners had organized in Germany. It presented everyday obstacles people come across in open spaces. This was the inspiration for a photography exhibit that we organized in Vienna in 1991 titled: Who Owns Public Space — Women’s Everyday Life in the City. It depicted the daily routines of a diverse group of women as they went about their lives in Vienna. They had different social backgrounds, represented different age groups and had a different level of mobility. One of them for example was a Turkish housewife, the other a single parent but there was also a workaholic manager and a student in a wheelchair.
Each woman tracked a different route through the city. The images made it clear that safety and ease of movement were a priority for all of them. This exhibit was in a way the beginning of, well, everything. We started to focus on public spaces and pedestrian issues and parks and playgrounds. That was new because, unlike today, at the time nobody talked about public spaces. It was definitely not a part of the mainstream planning field. It was as if pedestrians didn’t exist.
The 1981 exhibition was the first time the obstacles women faced in their daily lives in the city were brought to the public’s attention. (Source: Robert Hutterer, Municipal Archive of Vienna)
I read that, in connection to the exhibition, the pedestrian and traffic data was analyzed in a segregated manner for the first time in Vienna’s history. Is this true? What did it reveal?
E.K.: Yes, we looked at the numbers and it was an absolute eye opener to see that two thirds of car trips at that time were carried out by men and two thirds of trips on foot were carried out by women. But we also talked about topics such as spaces of fear and anxiousness regarding safety issues, sexual harassment but also spaces where women felt good. This was the first time these issues appeared in the public discourse.
Could you expand on what you mean when you say the exhibit was the beginning of everything?
E.K.: The exhibit was very successful and this was very important for future projects. We had about 4000 visitors and it also received a lot of media coverage. Even the Swiss late evening news reported on the exhibit. And the politicians also reacted very well to the issue and became interested in the topic which is always very important.
Up till then we did not have a women’s office for equal treatment within the administration. In other federal states it had already existed but not in Vienna. Usually this meant one woman was appointed who sat in a small office but we didn’t have even that. After the exhibit they created Vienna’s first women’s office, the so-called Frauenburo and asked me to be the head of it.As a department it had staff and several coworkers from the beginning.
It must have been quite an honor to be appointed but also a quite a stressful position to be in. Was it?
E.K.: Yes. Of course. I was extremely young, I was 32 and in the beginning I had no idea how to do it. The Frauenburo also dealt with several non-planning related topics such as the drafting of the equal treatment law and management of shelter facilities for women so heading the office was really a huge challenge. But then we got down to doing the job.
What problems did you gain insight to from your new position?
E.K.: At the time – as is the case today – there was a rapid growth period in Vienna and design competitions where necessary. Most of the development took place on the outskirts of the city, mostly on land in agricultural use or greenlands. So it needed urban design proposas for a new zoning plan and building regulations.The architects who could plan these were selected through competitions but ones you had to be invited to. What we noticed was that none of the women planners were ever invited to these urban design competitions. The future spaces of the city were being planned exclusively by men and so we proposed – inspired once again by German and Swiss examples – to have a competition specifically for women architects.This is how Frauen-Werk-Stadt I. was born. Competitors had to submit proposals for a social housing project north of the city, with women’s everyday life an essential criterion of the design for the 360 units.
The Frauen-Werk-Stadt I. initiative created more than 350 homes that were designed exclusively by women and centered around womens’ everyday life and experiences. (Source: Ágnes Győr)
The next step was to gender-mainstream the public space. The district chosen for a pilot project was Mariahilf, a densely populated central neighborhood with about 28,000 residents. During 2002 to 2006, street lighting was improved in 26 areas identified in surveys as inducing anxiety; traffic lights were altered to prioritize pedestrians; and seating was installed in nine new locations. More than a kilometer of pavement was widened, and five areas were made entirely barrier-free, so as to better accommodate prams, wheelchair users and elderly people.
You also redesigned the parks and playgrounds in the city. What was wrong with them?
E.K.: Two well known Austrian feminist sociologists came to us and said they want to finance a study because they know playgrounds in Germany reserved for girls but they are on private ground.. The Frauenbüro charged them to make a study based on 36 parks and playgrounds in Vienna in the inner, dense districts.. They watched and spoke to the children and it became very evident that we do indeed have a problem. After the age of 12 there were less girls in these places than boys. The playgrounds were usually quite small and and the ball play facilities were surrounded with high fences to protect the others. I myself remember that as a child it was clear to me that these are places reserved for boys and it never occurred to me to enter them. There was no sign but there was no question about it. so I was very interested in what the background of this might be. The study authors described it as the jungle law. The young male grown ups shused the small boys out and both groups are convinced, no place for girls. Its a question of the strength of appropriation.This study created awareness and then there was a mixed workshop between local politicians and people from the administration.
We redesigned two parks in the Margareten district in July 1999. We eventually ended up doing six pilot projects altogether between 1999 and 2000. The first two were invited competitions, the others were based on participation using different tools to involve girls. We evaluated all these and based on the evaluation we formed the general recommendations. These turned into the gender-sensitivity guidelines which apply to all parks citywide since 2005. Everything during the implementation of the process was as it should have been. It was a perfect example of how to turn gender experts’ local knowledge into general guidelines for the whole municipality.This is mainstreaming at its best as every new or redesigned park in Vienna follows the principles.
Nobody likes to getting hit on the head with a ball but what are some specific elements that make parks and playgrounds equally inviting for both boys and girls?
E.K.: For example larger areas dedicated to soccer have to be divided into smaller spaces so that multiple groups can play; creating additional seating areas, such as hammocks, to retreat is also important as is having public clean toilets, change tables in or close to parks and playgrounds. Footpaths across parks must be well lit.
Einsiedlerpark was one of the first playgrounds to be redesigned in a gender sensitive way. (Source: Wikipedia)
There are other cities where progressive projects have been launched focusing on inclusive planning but through the years it is Vienna which earned international reputation as the „city of equality”. What is the key to Vienna’s success?
E.K.: I think one factor that played a key role in our case is that Vienna has a very long social democratic tradition and the social democrats always had a very strong women’s organization, so women issues here, compared to the rest of Austria, were always more powerful. There is a kind of quite close exchange between politicians and administrations. You could see this critical, but I see an positive impact in this case. To be able to change things you need the experts in the administration and you also need supportive politicians. This is very important. The reason we could advance a bit further than other cities is because there was this play between these two atmospheres.
In the case of redesigning the parks and playgrounds in the beginning there was quite a lot of resistance from the gardening department which administer green areas. But with the pilot project we proved that the new approach was a step in the direction of creating better life quality for everyone.
What arguments do those who are against gender mainstreaming have?
E.K.: There is resistance at different levels. One is the personal level. There are men who might have problems with their wife, suffered a painful, humiliating breakup or have a dominating mother, and have psychological reasons for resisting. But, there are also women, who are not on board with the concept. Especially women at the top who identify with men and are dependent on men and don’t want to weaken their position by associating themselves with this “ women stuff.. The truth is that within a system you will find quite a lot of women who are not supportive of women’s issues.
My experience it is always best not to argue on this psychological personal level and to try to separate these sentiments from the professional arguments. When I talk to people I ask for professional behavior on their part. I say this is the professional aim, this is the political goal and our job is to figure out how to achieve it.
But resistance can also come from a different background, from the institutional framework and working conditions. There are those who say, we understand the goal but we don’t know how to achieve it, and also many times there is a burden of high workload in the system. The people you have to work with feel that they are behind with their work and then someone, an organization for example, comes along and tells them from the outside that they are doing their work wrong and should make extra efforts. Obviously this creates a bad atmosphere. You can support this with working aids and keep the workload realistic.
There are challenges to overcome but that is why pilot projects must be well designed. They must not seem threatening at first sight and must be eventually successful. When designing them you have to choose your goals very carefully and realistically. If you are too enthusiastic and want too much, you risk failure and that jeopardizes support for future ventures. One also always has to take into account that a big part of planning a successful project is allocating enough time and having enough resources. These are all very decisive. The real challenge is the roll out, the structural transformation.
Wide pavements in many places in Vienna signal that pedestrians are not seen as secondary compared to drivers. (Source: Ágnes Győr)
Many of the successful urban planning projects you mentioned involved participation. Is citizen engagement today a core part of how public issues are dealt with in Vienna?
E.K.: The attitude has changed significantly, nevertheless it is still not something that is automatic and there are several challenges when we talk about participation. You have to find the right tools and modes to involve the silent and timid members of the public. If you just send an invitation to a local forum to every household you can be sure that only a very specific group will show up and it will be made up of upper middle class car owners, dog owners and property owners. This leads to bias which is very dangerous because naturally politicians are impressed by loud people. So you really have to use low threshold methods, for example the kind we used when deciding how to re-design Reumannplatz in 2020.
For example, we had multilingual feminist landscape planners on the site for weeks with visualized versions of the possible plans offering coffee and cakes to passersby asking people to vote on how they would like to see the square transformed. After a while we noticed girls weren’t giving as much feedback as boys so I started going up to girls specifically to ask them to vote. Of course, even with these methods, the opinion of certain parts of the public might still be missing in the end. For example those of homeless people. They are one of the most intense users of public spaces but they will not come forward by themselves. You have to specifically go up to them and talk to them.
Are there new challenges facing gender inclusive urban planning?
E.K.: What is a realistic, huge challenge for urban planning is climate change and adapting to climate change. I believe there could be a very strong synthesis between gender issues and climate related issues. For example in terms of temperature rise the most vulnerable people are elderly people and women because women start to suffer from heat earlier than men. Analyzing data is very important. With all the changes we are facing there is a huge need to transform our cities and economies and it is necessary that this be done in a gender sensitive way.
I have children and I am very passionate about this topic. I know making good decisions, finding solutions is not just a conversation about our comfort level, but about their life, their future.
The good news is that for the first time the ecologically necessary transformation supports the vulnerable groups because creating more green spaces, more public transportation, more bike routes are both sustainable and help the poor, who currently have the least access to these. New energy saving systems also all support the vulnerable groups. I believe there are strong synthesis between climate and gender issues.gender planning as a strategy of quality assessments can be a powerfull support for fighting the climate crisis..
Vienna has come a very long way but there is always space for improvement. In 5 years what would Vienna look like ideally?
E.K.: In the coming years I would like to mobilize the support of women and female experts. We had a huge transformation of cities in the 19th century with the industrial revolution and at the time it was led by basically only male engineers. I think we have been given a new chance and also an urgent need to once again have a huge impact on cities but this time in a much more holistic way with much more involvement on the part of women, not just experts but also everyday women. We need the citizens. We need trees but this means parking cars have to go, we need people to water the plants, civil engagement in my opinion will become much more important in the future. But I am optimistic. Our experience from Vienna shows that many women are willing and want to engage. The experts know what has to be done and politicians have to find a way to survive taking the necessary steps but in the end the citizens create the atmosphere of change
—
The interview was organized with the help of Eurocomm-PR Budapest.
The featured picture and the cover picture were taken by Jana Madzigon and are the courtesy of Eva Kail.